Does the SAT Have A Racial Bent?
For years, the SAT has come under attack for having a certain bent. From the Harvard Educational Review to the Princeton Review, the measurement tool has been called a “white preference test.”
Last year, Harvard published a study arguing that SAT questions in the verbal section favored white students by using language with which they were more familiar compared to other non-white groups. The study said black students of equal academic aptitude scored lower on the section, Education Week reported.
But FairTest, an organization that focuses on fairness and accuracy in student testing and scoring, doesn’t think it’s just the questions on the SAT that are the problem. In a recent interview with CNN, Monty Neill, FairTest deputy director, says the issue is that schools rely too heavily on the SAT in admission decisions. He says that one test is not the best predictor of college success.
“In a technical sense, it’s probably not a biased test. The problems become in how it gets used in admissions process,” he said. “Most colleges will use the SAT as one piece of evidence, but a lot of them will use it to weed out a whole lot of kids who never then get a chance.”
The problem is that the process hurts minority kids, who traditionally score lower on the test, he says.
“So what happens is kids of color — black kids, Hispanic kids — are going to get left out. They’re going to be predicted to not do well.”
However, Laurence Bunin, senior vice president of the SAT program at the College Board, tells CNN the SAT is, in fact, an indicator of college success:
“FairTest is mistaken on this point. The research is very clear and there are many, many many studies that say the SAT is absolutely predictive of how well students wil do in college as well as whether they’ll stay in college.”
The College Board has conducted studies that report that in some cases, SAT scores were even more predictive than high school grade point average.
Bunin says the questions are tested with students of different races and “walks of life” and says that score disparities can be attributed to the achievement gap nationwide.
“The test is a fair test that helps mirror what’s going on in this country.”
As an alternative to admittance based on SAT scores, FairTest says students have the option of 830 colleges that make the test optional for some or all applicants.
Colleges such as Drew University in New Jersey allow students to submit an essay graded by a teacher rather than submitting an SAT score.
Jonathan Grayer, CEO of Kaplan Educational Centers, tells PBS he thinks the SAT has limitations and biases, but that the test can’t be done away with because it’s the fairest system there is. Without it, he says, there’d be “a lot more outcry of favoritism.”
“If there’s something better out there, we should use it. If there’s something affordable that we can create, we should all by all means do it. But at the end of the day, that’s a very serious proposition, deciding if a child gets in or not, and the SAT helps.”